Teacher Bette

The Welsh mining town of Glansarno is in a tizzy - the new owner of one of the larger estates is arriving that day. They are shocked to discover that LC Moffat, M.A. is a woman - Lily Cristobel Moffat (Bette Davis), an educated woman who intends to use her inheritance to start a school for the local children. She enlists the services of Mr. Jones (Rhys Williams) and Miss Ronberry (Mildred Dunnock) to act as instructors in her free school but despite the high levels of illiteracy in the town, she finds herself in a battle with Sir Trevorby, the local Squire (Nigel Bruce) and pub owner Will Davis (Arthur Shields), both of whom see the school as a threat to their livelihoods.  Our film this week is The Corn is Green (1945).

Bette Davis shines as the tough-as-nails Miss Moffat in this retelling of the Broadway play.  Loosely based on the life of  playwright Emlyn Williams, the Broadway production starred Ethel Barrymore as the independent educator. Ms. Davis was only 36 when she took on the part - and would later say that she was perhaps a bit too young (Ms. Barrymore was 61 when she appeared in the play, and Miss Moffat was supposed to be in her 50s) - but Bette Davis was not averse to looking older for the film (TCM article). She brings grit and, when required, warmth to this single-minded woman.

The film introduced Joan Lorring (Bessie Watty) to the screen. Bessie is an avaricious, nasty piece of work, though with her mother, it's not hard to imagine WHY Bessie is the manipulator that she is. She especially loathes Miss Moffat (who she sees as the reason for everything that is wrong with her life), and goes out of her way to strike out at her nemesis.  Originally, Bette Davis wanted Ida Lupino for the role of Bessy Watty (Dark Victory: The Life of Bette Davis by Ed Sikov), but she was not available.  Angela Lansbury, Betty Field, and Andrea King were all tested - Ms. Davis selected Ms. Lorring, who got an Oscar nomination in the supporting actress category, and who called Ms. Davis one of her "teachers". 

Though Richard Waring (who played Morgan Evans on stage) was director Irving Rapper's first choice, Mr. Waring's military service prevented him from being cast. John Dall, like Ms. Lorring, was introduced for this film. He's convincing as Morgan, who goes from flippant to bitter to ambitious, and all done with great conviction. His scenes with Ms. Davis are especially strong - he would credit her with assisting in his performance - in his close up scenes, Ms. Davis stood "behind the camera, facing me, giving the scene the same acting as if she were before the camera."

Several wonderful actors repeated their Broadway roles. Mildred Dunnock who doesn't know how to give a bad performance, reprised Miss Ronberry; Rhys Williams as the minister Mr. Jones and Sara Pugh (Gwyneth Hughes) are also excellent (AFI Catalog),. Nigel Bruce, however, was new to the cast and is at his fubsy best as the rather clueless Squire.  Also added to the film cast was Arthur Shields, who makes a menacing publican. 

Also repeating her Broadway role was Rosalind Ivan (Mrs. Watty). Mrs. Watty is both funny and dismaying simultaneously. Her utter disregard for her daughter makes the viewer want to cringe - then again, with a daughter like Bessie, it's hard to argue with Mrs. Watty's attitude.  Ms. Ivan was over 60 when she played Mrs. Watty, yet you believe her as Bessie's mother - her face, while not that of a beauty, is also not old.  Because she frequently played women who were not very likeable, she acquired the nickname "Ivan the Terrible" (Accustomed to Her Face: Thirty-Five Character Actresses of Golden Age Hollywood by Axel Nissen). Ms. Ivan would continue in films for another nine years after The Corn is Green,  including Johnny Belinda (1948) and Scarlet Street (1945). After appearances in a couple of television shows, she retired.

One interesting aspect of the film (which is set in 1898) is that part of Miss Moffat's mission is to teach English to the locals. As was done in Ireland and Scotland, use of the native language was banned in place of English. Though it did not always prevent the locals from using the language, its use in the courts or even in places of business was illegal (Historic UK). As time progressed, Welsh began to die out; there were fears that it would no longer have any native speakers. However, in recent years, the number of native speakers has risen, and there is now hope the spoken language will continue to live (BBC).

As mentioned, the film was based on the 1940 Broadway play by Emlyn Williams with Ethel Barrymore as Miss Moffat. There were three other productions of the play: 1943 (with Miss Barrymore); 1950 (Eva La Gallienne); 1983 (Cicely Tyson). There was also an unsuccessful attempt of a musical (starring Bette Davis in the title role and Dorian Harewood as Morgan Evans) - Miss Moffat - that never made it to Broadway.  Helen Hayes took on the lead in the December 1947 Theater Guild of the Air radio production.  Lux Radio Theatre presented the story twice - with Olivia de Havilland and Richard Basehart as the teacher and student, in June of 1950 and again with Claudette Colbert and Cameron Mitchell in May of 1954. The story also made it to television in 1979, with Katharine Hepburn as Miss Moffat.

While Bosley Crowther enjoyed Bette Davis' performance in the film, his review in The New York Times was not complimentary of the director nor of the film overall, saying "this humble, human story is not as intimate and moving on the screen as it was on the stage." But, Mr. Crowther spends a lot of copy comparing the film to Ms. Barrymore's stage performance - a performance that (unfortunately) that the rest of us will never be privileged to see.

We all enjoyed the film thoroughly, and heartily recommend it for your enjoyment.  We'll leave you with a trailer: