Thomas Has a Theory

 

Professor Henry Todhunter (Thomas Mitchell) has been diagnosed by his friend, Dr. Lawrence Stevens (James Stephenson) with severe coronary disease; he has, at most, six months to live. University Dean Somers (Thurston Hall) forces Todhunter’s retirement; with nothing better to do, Professor Todhunter spends his days developing new theories. He hypothetically asks his colleagues what they would do if they had only six months to live. Professor Peterson (John Eldredge) has a disturbing idea - murder someone who the law cannot touch but deserves to die. Our film this week is Flight from Destiny (1941).

This is a nicely paced mystery story that will keep you guessing through the entire film. The cast is led by Thomas Mitchell, who is wonderful as the dying man. Mr. Mitchell keeps the character just teetering on the edge of sanity - when he proposes his theory that, as he is neither living nor dead, he has the authority to judge the right of another being to live, you wonder if he is sincere. Discovering he is indeed deadly serious (no pun intended), one is chilled to the bone.

Without going into too much detail, some of the plot focuses on an art forging racket.  This is worth noting, as Thomas Mitchell was himself and art collector, who it is believed, was the victim of a forger.  He reportedly purchased a forged Rembrandt, that is currently in the Fogg Museum at Harvard. (Hollywood’s Original Rat Pack: The Bards of Bundy Drive by Stephen C. Jordan)

First billing in the film is given to Geraldine Fitzgerald (Betty Farroway), but don't expect to see her very much. Her character is crucial to the film, setting Professor Todhunter on his mission of "justice," but Ms. Fitzgerald has little to do but look pained.  It's a shame really; she's a talented actress and uses what screen time she has well. 

Jeffrey Lynn (Michael Farroway) is also convincing in the part of the erring husband. Mr. Lynn doesn't often get roles that allow him to do much more than be handsome, but this one gives him a part he can sink his teeth in, and we were impressed with is performance.

On the other hand Mona Maris (Ketti Moret) left something to be desired in the part of the thief and seductress.  Ms. Marris is a striking woman, but but doesn't have all that much allure. The character was supposed to use her charms to win over her victims; while we only see her briefly with Michael, we do see her with Professor Todhunter at some length.  She is just too cold to be convincing as a woman whose primary gift is allegedly her sexual appeal. She does get to show off some remarkable dresses by designer Damon Giffard (who worked in Hollywood for only one year).

Mary Gordon as Professor Todhunter's housekeeper,  Martha is worth comment.  Though a small part, it's a good character that is well acted by Ms. Gordon. And, if you are a fan of Alexis Smith, she appears in a small role. That same year, she'd appear in Dive Bomber with Errol Flynn (TCM article).

Based on the 1937 novel Trial and Error by Anthony Berkeley Cox, it had two working titles: that of the book and Invitation to a Murder (AFI Catalog). It garnered a very positive review from Thomas M. Pryor in the New York Times, saying that "it was most fortunate that an actor of Mr. Mitchell's ability was selected to interpret [Professor Todhunter].

All in all, this is a little-viewed film that deserves some attention. Do try to find it.