Aldo is on the Run

James Vanning (Aldo Ray) goes into a Los Angeles bar for a drink, where he is approached by Marie Gardner (Anne Bancroft). She's got a problem - she was meeting a girlfriend for a drink and walked off without her wallet; would Jim loan her a small amount of money to pay for the drink she purchased? Jim agrees to help her; they strike up a conversation and decide to dine together. When they leave the restaurant, Jim is kidnapped by two criminals, John (Brian Keith) and Red (Rudy Bond), who plan to torture him for the location of something. We're going to discuss Nightfall (1957).

When I attend Noir City DC, I  try to select some films I've never seen before - sometimes ones I've never even heard of. This picture fell into the latter category. I openly confess to not being a particular fan of Aldo Ray, but after seeing this film, my opinion of his acting abilities has soared upward. Mr. Ray is both engaging and sympathetic as a man on the run both from the gangsters that want him to reveal the location of stolen funds, and from the police who believe he has committed a murder.

This was by no means Anne Bancroft's first appearance - she'd started in television, and made her big screen debut with Marilyn Monroe and Richard Widmark in Don't Bother to Knock (1952). She makes a lovely addition to Nightfall, appearing as a mannequin (modeling gowns created by fashion director Winifred Waring (AFI catalog)) at a local couture house, who becomes romantically involved with Jim.  In a sense, as is pointed out in this TCM article, the character is somewhat unnecessary to the story line, but she is so very engaging that you really don't notice. 

Brian Keith plays a truly despicable villain, though he's not nearly as bad as his murderous colleague, played with appropriate madness by Rudy Bond. Mr. Keith's calm delivery emphasizes how truly heinous John is. He commits murder with the ease of putting on a jacket. There is no guilt or emotion - it is just a task that he must perform.

It's always a pleasure to see Frank Albertson, here playing Dr. Edward Gurston, Jim's (or Art Rayburn; James Vanning is a pseudonym) best friend and camping partner. It's a small part, but he is, as always, enjoyable.Though he is only present for a few scenes, his character is crucial to the actions that follow, and his presence is felt through out the film.

Early in the film, we are introduced to Ben Fraser (James Gregory) and his wife, Laura (Jocelyn Brando). Their relationship is lovely - their marriage is obviously strong, and they are not afraid to tease one another about his job. James Gregory presents a man who is good at his job, and is also scrupulously honest. Though the authorities suspect Jim of robbery and murder, Ben has his doubts, based only on observation and a brief conversation between the two men. Ben's trust in Jim becomes a key factor as the plot thickens.

James Gregory started his acting career in New York (he was born in the Bronx and raised in New Rochelle) in the Broadway production of Key Largo. He would appear in 14 Broadway productions during his lifetime. After a three-year Navy stint, he did more theatre and radio - his distinctive, gravelly voice made him a natural. His first film role was as a police officer in The Naked City (1948); he's probably best remembered for his role as Senator Iselin in The Manchurian Candidate (1962). He found a home guest starring in television series, including Star Trek, The Big Valley,  Hawaii Five-O, and Barney Miller, where he had a recurring part as Inspector Frank Luger. He retired in 1986, and lived with his wife of 58 years until his death at the age of 90 in 2002.

Director Jacques Tourneur  was no stranger to film noir - he'd already directed Out of the Past (1947), perhaps the penultimate film noir. Since then, attitudes towards television had changed, and the filmmakers, who had originally ignored it, realized the TV was another venue for their films after the screen time was over. However, noir's grey-shaded cinematography did not show up well on 1950s b&w televisions. The films looked muddy. So, Mr. Tourneur brought in cinematographer Burnett Guffey to create a look that would show more clearly on early TV sets (PaleyFest). This included moving the film from Los Angeles, where it opened, to the mountains of Wyoming. The result - the film becomes truly black and white - with the stark, white mountains and snow-covered fields, contrasting with the  dark trees and water. It's a beautiful piece of work.

The New York Times review was dismissive, though the reviewer complimented the actors on a job well done (he's particularly impressed with Brian Keith and James Gregory - I agree).  The evaluation of the film has changed in recent years, as is evidenced by this Huffington Post article, calling it "work of striking juxtapositions and tones that by picture end, come off like an unforgettably disarming person — you’re charmed, discombobulated, even slightly disturbed, and you’re not sure what to make of it all. You just know you like it, no matter how bizarre it all ends up."

I heartily recommend you look for this film - I think you will enjoy it. In the meantime, here is a trailer: