Barbara Shoots (at a Target)

Annie Oakley (1935) stars Barbara Stanwyck as the legendary sharpshooter Annie Oakley.  The story is loosely based on Annie's early years in the entertainment industry, when she broke into the business by competing against a male rifleman, here named Toby Walker (Preston Foster).  And while the film does get a lot of the information right, it takes many liberties with Ms. Oakley's life, not the least of which is that it changes the name of her partner and husband from Frank Butler.  Nevertheless, it's an entertaining film, as long as you realize it is "FILM history".

Young Annie Oakley is the main support of her family - her mother and younger siblings.  Annie is a crack shot; she hunts quail for an upscale Cincinnati hotel; as she able to hit the bird directly in the head, so no buckshot ruins the meat.  When Toby Walker, the new attraction for the Buffalo Bill Wild West Show stays at the hotel, the hotel manager, Mr. MacIvor (Andy Clyde), suggests a shooting match between Walker and the person who is supplying him with his game.  MacIvor, however believes his supplier is a man.  Annie is able to match Toby shot for shot, but when her mother overhears a discussion that Annie's win might cost Toby his position with Bill Cody, she encourages Annie to lose the match.  Annie, who finds Toby quite attractive, purposely misses her next shot. Regardless, her talent with a rifle is noted by Jeff Hogarth (Melvyn Douglas), who hires her for the Buffalo Bill Wild West Show.  Soon, Annie is the star of the show, with Ned Buntline (Dick Elliott) hinting at a bitter rivalry between Annie and Toby (for publicity), while Toby secretly teaches Annie showmanship, and while Toby and Annie fall in love.

Barbara Stanwyck as Annie Oakley

The real Annie Oakley

Let's start with a look at the real Annie Oakley.   She was born Phoebe Ann Moses in 1860, and following her father's death in 1866, she lived a life of privation.  After being sent to a foster home (she would only identify the people as "the wolves"), she eventually returned to her mother; she began hunting and was able through her work to pay off the mortgage on her family's home.  That same year (1875), she competed against Frank Butler in a Cincinnati challenge match, and won.  Butler was instantly fascinated by her, and the following year, they wed.  By 1882, she joined Frank's act - she was so popular that Frank became her manager and publicist, leaving the shooting to Annie.  After a long career, both with the Wild West Show and on stage, Annie retired.  The Butlers lived in retirement until her death in 1926.  Frank died 18 days later.   For an in-depth biography of the real Annie Oakley, as well as an analysis of Annie Oakley on Stage and Screen, visit: Annie Oakley (The American Experience).

What is really successful in this film is their ability to catch the romance between Annie and Toby.  The audience and Annie never question that the couple are deeply in love.   Surely, it plays fast and loose with the facts, but neither are demeaned.  Annie is clearly Toby's equal, and even after he is told (by her) that she let him win, he is not intimidated by her, but respects her abilities.  Stanwyck is especially vibrant in the role of Annie.  She is sweet when she needs to be, but proud of her abilities and not one to hide her light.  One scene especially shows Stanwyck at her best.  Alone in her room, Annie longs for Toby, whom her colleagues believe has purposefully injured her hand.  She knows the injury was accidental, but Toby has been fired by Bill Cody (Moroni Olsen), and Annie is unable to prevent it or even go to Toby.  Her pain radiates from her; the scene is done in silence.

This was Stanwyck's first film at RKO. She had been appearing in films at Warner Brothers and was dissatisfied with the parts she was receiving their.  She'd already ventured over to First National for The Woman in Red and to Edward Smalls (Reliance) for Red Comrade.  Her next film, A Message to Garcia, would be at 20th Century Fox.  In A Life of Barbara Stanwyck: Steel-True 1907-1940, Victoria Wilson stated that Stanwyck was "outside the protection of a single studio" (full quote at Rogerebert.com).  Perhaps this is why she never won an Oscar.  Regardless, it gave her the ability to control her own career to a degree that other actresses probably envied.  For more detail on Stanwyck's move to RKO, see this TCM article.

 

We focused a bit of our discussion on the male leads.  Melvyn Douglas appears in a secondary role with Preston Foster in the lead.  We wondered what the film would have been like had the roles been switched.

We've only seen a few films with Preston Foster, and in most of them he had a supporting role (for example, The Harvey Girls (1946) in which he plays the evil Sam Purvis to John Hodiak's heroic Ned Trent); he was briefly discussed when he appeared opposite Carole Lombard in Love Before Breakfast.  Foster had a long career, appearing in film and television til 1967. He had started on the Broadway stage, appearing in five plays between 1929 and 1932.  After that, he was Hollywood bound.  He also had a career as a vocalist and songwriter, appearing in trio consisting of himself, his wife Sheila Darcy (to whom he was married from 1946 until his death in 1970) and guitarist Gene Leis.  When Foster retired from acting, he took on the role of executive director of the El Camino Playhouse, where he wrote, directed and acted in plays (the Playhouse closed in 1966).  Preston Foster died in 1970, at the age of 69.

Also in the small role of Vera Delmar is Pert Kelton, whose distinct speaking voice is instantly recognizable. We've mentioned her before in our discussions of Cain and Mabel and Bed of Roses (wherein she plays the hooker, Minnie) - in this film, she plays a character much closer to that of Minnie.  Vera is a bit of a tramp; she's interested in Toby, and doesn't really care what she has to do to get him.  Kelton makes the most of her short screen time to create a memorable characterization.

Pert Kelton had a very varied career.  Her film career, in which she was generally the wisecracking buddy or a floozy, only lasted from 1929 to 1939.  After that, she seems to have moved back to the East Coast, where she appeared in radio.  In the 1950s, she appeared in short sketches the Cavalcade of Stars as Alice Norton - sketches that would give birth to the television show The Honeymooners.  Kelton, however would not continue on to the series - her husband Ralph Bell had become embroiled in the McCarthy Era blacklist, which led to her being dropped from the show. She did continue in small roles on Cavalcade, and it has been suggested that Gleason attempted to keep her working for as long as he could.  He, in fact, invited her to appear in The Color Honeymooners as Alice's mother (since, by that time Audrey Meadows had assumed the role of Alice). Ms. Kelton died in 1968 at the age of 61.  Though many of the episodes from Cavalcade are lost, here is a short bit with her that survives:

We leave you this time with a short clip from Annie Oakley - the shooting contest between Annie and Toby.  We'll be back soon with a discussion of a more recent film, as well as our evaluation of a Kay Francis film.  

Clark Boxes

When waitress  Mabel O'Dare (Marion Davies) loses her job thanks to Aloysius K. Reilly (Roscoe Karns), he gets the bright idea to introduce her to a Broadway producer.  Mabel ends up with a job, only because the star has just quit.  But there's a problem - Mabel can dance, a little, but not enough to lead a Broadway show.  Her dreams of stardom are all but gone when Reilly decides to get some publicity for her by claiming a love affair between Mabel and up-and-coming boxer Larry Cain (Clark Gable).  But again, there is a little problem - Larry and Mabel loathe one another.

Thus begins Cain and Mabel (1936), a little froth of a comedy, with a few musical numbers thrown in.  While it was fun to see Clark Gable in this very early role, and Marion Davies is a delightful performer, this was probably not the best movie either ever made.  The musical routines were a bit tedious - they ended up changing the tone of the film.  We know Mabel isn't a great dancer; all the routines do is emphasize that to no purpose.  And though the film is a bit long, there are some delightful scenes.  The early conversations between Reilly and Mabel are a hoot, and then there is the added presence of Allen Jenkins as Dodo, Larry's fight second. Any time Allen Jenkins is in a movie, you know you are going to have a good time.  

We also have Ruth Donnelly as Aunt Mimi, who is also very funny.  It should be mentioned though that Mimi is a fairly despicable person.  She will go to any lengths to advance Mabel's career, because it is keeping Aunt Mimi in the money.  She has no worry that her actions might make Mabel unhappy.   

Another interesting appearance is that of Pert Kelton as Toddy, the star whose departure makes way for Mabel.  We've seen her in Bed of Roses, and  as we mentioned then, later in her career as Shirley Jones' mother in The Music Man.  Unfortunately, she doesn't get a whole lot to do here, which is a shame.

Interestingly, Dick Powell was originally slated to play Ronny Caudwell, Mabel's co-star and almost boyfriend.  However, the part went to Robert Paige, because William Randolph Heart didn't like Dick Powell. Hearst felt Powell was too attractive and that Davies liked him too much.  As I'm sure everyone is aware, Heart and Davies were longtime companions.  An interesting bit of trivia - when Hearst was in financial trouble in the 1930s, it was Davies who came to his rescue. She was a very intelligent businesswoman, and used $1 million of her own money to bail him out (much of it invested in jewelry).

This TCM article also tells in some detail the story of how Clark Gable was cast as Larry.  Davies did NOT want him in the part - she didn't think he was attractive enough to play Larry!  She later changed her mind about him, but Gable never quite forgot the insult.  All we have to say is HUH?  Gable not attractive? On what planet?

The film is a remake of  the silent film The Great White Way, which was filmed by Hearst's company in 1924, which starred Anita Stewart.  And while we can't whole-heartedly recommend this one, it has some nice moments.  And then there is Gable.  We close with the film's trailer:

Connie Gets a Bed

Lorry Evans (Constance Bennett) has just been released from prison. She and her friend Minnie Brown (Pert Kelton) board a steamboat, in hopes of fleecing some of the men on board.  Only, Lorry is discovered, so she jumps overboard.  And is fished out of the water by Dan (Joel McCrea) the captain of a nearby barge. Having lost the money she scammed while on board the steamboat, Lorry takes Dan's money, and heads for New Orleans.  Thus begins Bed of Roses from 1933, the latest in our Constance Bennett series.  

This film is so obviously pre-code!  Lorry and Minnie are being released from prison for soliciting.  They are scam artists, and once Lorry gets to New Orleans, her goal is to sucker a rich man (John Halliday as Stephen Paige) into becoming her sugar daddy.   And yet, it will all end well for our "heroine".  Here is a clip from the opening scene:

 

Of course, we will discover that Lorry has a code, and will return to Dan because he is a good guy.  And she will fall in love with him.  And then her life will become even more complicated, as she has to decide between love and the knowledge of what her past life will do to their relationship.  Bennett is fantastic in the part.  She makes Lorry hard to dislike, yet you are always aware that she really is not quite on the up-and-up.  We also, of course, get some beautiful clothing once Lorry has gotten herself properly set up (no costumer is listed for the film, unfortunately).

The men are interesting characters as well.  Dan is a really good guy.  This is NOT the McCrea of Primrose Path (which we previously discussed).  This Dan takes people as they are; he doesn't make judgements.  Similarly, Stephen Paige actually seems to love Lorry.  Considering how she wormed her way into his life, this is rather surprising, however John Halliday, an excellent character actor who we've discussed before, makes it work.

Finally, there is Pert Kelton.  For those not familiar with her right away, this is Ma from The Music Man!  Minnie is hysterical, and Ms. Kelton plays her for all she is worth.  She reminds one a bit of Mae West.  And watch for the ending.  You will be quite amused.

Pert Kelton with John Halliday

Next time, another Constance Bennett pre-code